Delmonico Potatoes Recipe

Delmonico Potatoes are the epitome of comfort food with a touch of sophistication. Originating from the famed Delmonico’s restaurant in 19th-century New York, this dish features shredded potatoes enveloped in a velvety cheddar cheese sauce, subtly spiced with dry mustard and nutmeg, then baked until golden and bubbly. What sets this recipe apart is its *make-ahead convenience*—the overnight refrigeration allows the potatoes to fully absorb the creamy sauce, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth texture. Whether you’re preparing for a holiday feast, a dinner party, or a cozy family meal, this classic side dish delivers rich flavor and effortless elegance.

PIN THIS!PIN THIS!

Preparation Phase & Essential Tools

Before diving into the recipe, gather the right tools to ensure seamless preparation:

• 8×8-inch casserole dish – The ideal size for even baking and a golden crust. Butter it generously to prevent sticking.
• Saucepan – A medium-sized, heavy-bottomed pan prevents the dairy-based sauce from scorching.
• Whisk – Essential for creating a smooth, lump-free cheese sauce.
• Measuring cups and spoons – Precision matters for balancing flavors, especially with spices like nutmeg and dry mustard.
• Plastic wrap – Crucial for covering the dish during refrigeration, which enhances flavor absorption.

Why These Tools Matter

Using the right equipment ensures consistency. A casserole dish promotes even heat distribution, while a saucepan with a thick base prevents the milk and cream from curdling. Skipping the whisk might leave clumps in your cheese sauce, and inaccurate measurements could throw off the dish’s delicate seasoning.

Preparation Tips for Best Results

• Shred potatoes uniformly – If using fresh potatoes (like Yukon Gold), ensure even shreds for consistent cooking.
• Freshly grate nutmeg – Pre-ground nutmeg loses potency; freshly grated adds a warm, aromatic depth.
• Cool the sauce slightly – Pouring boiling-hot cheese sauce over potatoes can make them mushy. Let it cool for 5 minutes.
• Press potatoes into the dish – An even layer ensures every bite is coated in creamy goodness.

Ingredients List

For the perfect Delmonico Potatoes, you’ll need:

• 20 oz pre-shredded Simply Potatoes – Or substitute with freshly shredded Yukon Gold or Russet potatoes.
• 3/4 cup milk – Whole milk adds richness, but 1% or 2% works for a lighter version.
• 3/4 cup whipping cream – The key to the sauce’s luxurious texture.
• 1 teaspoon kosher salt – Enhances all flavors without overpowering.
• 1 teaspoon dry mustard – Adds a subtle tang that complements the cheese.
• Freshly ground black pepper – To taste, for a mild kick.
• Freshly grated nutmeg – Just a pinch elevates the dish.
• 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese – Melts smoothly and provides bold flavor.
• 3 tablespoons butter – Sliced into pats for topping.
• Paprika – A light sprinkle for color and a hint of smokiness.

Step-by-Step Directions

1. Prepare the casserole dish – Generously butter an 8×8-inch baking dish and spread the shredded potatoes in an even layer.
2. Make the cheese sauce – In a saucepan over medium-high heat, combine milk, whipping cream, kosher salt, dry mustard, black pepper, and nutmeg. Stir constantly until the mixture is nearly boiling.
3. Melt the cheese – Reduce heat to low and gradually stir in the shredded cheddar cheese until fully melted and smooth. Remove from heat.
4. Assemble the casserole – Pour the warm cheese sauce evenly over the potatoes. Let it sit for 5 minutes to slightly cool before covering.
5. Refrigerate overnight – Tightly cover the dish with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 12 hours (or up to 24 hours). This step is non-negotiable for the best texture.
6. Bake to perfection – Preheat the oven to 350°F. Remove the plastic wrap, dot the top with butter slices, and sprinkle lightly with paprika. Bake uncovered for 45 minutes, or until the top is golden and the edges are bubbly.

Tips & Variations

• Cheese swaps – Try Gruyère for a nuttier flavor or pepper jack for a spicy twist.
• Add-ins – Mix in crispy bacon, caramelized onions, or sautéed mushrooms for extra depth.
• Herb garnish – Fresh thyme or chives add a bright, fresh contrast.

This Delmonico Potatoes recipe is a foolproof way to impress guests or elevate a weeknight dinner. The creamy, cheesy layers and golden crust make it a standout side dish that pairs beautifully with roasted meats or holiday mains.

Delmonico Potatoes shine as a versatile side dish, but serving them correctly ensures they’re the star of the meal. Whether you’re hosting a holiday dinner or a casual family gathering, pairing this creamy, cheesy casserole with complementary dishes elevates the entire dining experience. Below, we’ll explore ideal serving styles, common pitfalls to avoid, and eight perfect side dishes that harmonize with this classic recipe.

Serving Suggestions for Maximum Appeal

Presentation matters when serving Delmonico Potatoes. Here’s how to make them look as good as they taste:

• Garnish for Visual Appeal – A sprinkle of fresh chopped chives or parsley adds a pop of color against the golden-brown crust. For a touch of elegance, top with a light dusting of smoked paprika or microgreens.
• Serve in the Baking Dish – The rustic charm of a ceramic or cast-iron casserole dish keeps the potatoes warm and makes for easy family-style serving.
• Portion Control – Use a sharp spatula to cut clean squares or wedges, ensuring each serving has a crisp top layer and creamy center.
• Temperature Matters – Serve immediately after baking while the cheese sauce is luxuriously gooey. If needed, keep warm in a 200°F oven for up to 20 minutes before serving.

Common Mistakes & How to Avoid Them

Even the simplest recipes can go awry. Here are the top mistakes people make with Delmonico Potatoes and how to fix them:

• Skipping the Overnight Rest – Refrigeration is non-negotiable. It allows the potatoes to absorb the sauce fully, preventing a watery texture. If short on time, chill for at least 6 hours (though 12+ is ideal).
• Underseasoning the Sauce – The potatoes need bold flavor. Taste the cheese sauce before pouring and adjust salt, pepper, or mustard if needed. Remember, potatoes mellow spices during baking.
• Overbaking – Baking beyond 45 minutes can dry out the dish. Check at the 40-minute mark—the top should be golden, and the edges bubbly. If browning too quickly, tent with foil.
• Using Low-Fat Dairy – Substituting milk or cream with low-fat versions sacrifices richness. Stick to whole milk and heavy cream for the creamiest results.
• Uneven Potato Shreds – Pre-shredded potatoes save time, but if using fresh, ensure uniform thickness. Thick shreds stay crunchy; thin ones turn mushy.

8 Perfect Side Dishes to Pair

Delmonico Potatoes pair beautifully with proteins and vegetables that balance their richness. Here are eight foolproof options:

1. Herb-Roasted Chicken – Juicy, golden chicken with rosemary or thyme cuts through the potatoes’ creaminess.
2. Garlic Butter Steak – A medium-rare ribeye or filet mignon adds a luxurious, savory contrast.
3. Honey-Glazed Carrots – The sweetness of caramelized carrots offsets the cheesy, savory notes.
4. Creamed Spinach – A classic pairing, especially for holiday meals like Christmas or Easter.
5. Cranberry Walnut Salad – Tart cranberries and crunchy walnuts provide a refreshing, textural contrast.
6. Buttery Dinner Rolls – Ideal for soaking up any extra cheese sauce left on the plate.
7. Grilled Asparagus – Lightly charred spears add a smoky, fresh element.
8. Beef Tenderloin – A holiday-worthy main that lets the potatoes shine as a supporting act.

How to Perfect the Recipe Every Time

For flawless Delmonico Potatoes, follow these pro tips:

• Grate Your Own Cheese – Pre-shredded cheese contains anti-caking agents that can make the sauce grainy. Freshly grated cheddar melts smoother.
• Let the Dish Rest After Baking – Allow 5–10 minutes before serving so the sauce thickens slightly.
• Customize the Spice Level – Add a pinch of cayenne or a dash of hot sauce to the cheese mixture for a subtle kick.
• Test for Doneness – Insert a knife into the center; it should slide through tender potatoes with minimal resistance.

With these serving tips, avoidance of common errors, and well-paired sides, your Delmonico Potatoes will steal the show at any meal.

Delmonico Potatoes are a dish worth savoring—even after the first serving. Whether you’ve made a large batch for a crowd or have leftovers to enjoy later, proper storage and reheating techniques ensure the dish retains its creamy texture and rich flavor. Below, we’ll cover essential tips for keeping your potatoes fresh, answer frequently asked questions, and provide final recommendations for mastering this classic recipe.

Storage & Reheating Instructions

Refrigerating Leftovers

• Cool Completely Before Storing – Allow the potatoes to reach room temperature (no more than 2 hours at room temp) before transferring to an airtight container. This prevents condensation, which can make the dish soggy.
• Store Properly – Keep leftovers in a sealed container or wrap the baking dish tightly with aluminum foil. They will stay fresh for 3–4 days in the refrigerator.
• Reheating in the Oven – For best results, reheat at 325°F in an oven-safe dish, covered with foil, for 15–20 minutes. Uncover for the last 5 minutes to crisp the top.
• Microwave Option – While not ideal, microwaving in 30-second intervals with a splash of milk can revive smaller portions. Stir between intervals to distribute heat evenly.

Freezing for Long-Term Storage

• Portion Before Freezing – Cut the casserole into individual servings and wrap each tightly in plastic wrap, then aluminum foil. This prevents freezer burn and allows for easy reheating.
• Use Within 3 Months – While frozen potatoes can last longer, the texture is best within this timeframe.
• Thawing & Reheating – Defrost overnight in the refrigerator before reheating in the oven at 325°F for 25–30 minutes, or until heated through.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Use Fresh Potatoes Instead of Pre-Shredded?

Yes, but pat them dry thoroughly after shredding to remove excess starch and moisture. Excess liquid can lead to a soggy casserole.

Can I Make This Recipe Gluten-Free?

Absolutely. The dish is naturally gluten-free as long as you ensure all ingredients (especially the cheese and spices) are certified gluten-free.

Why Is the Overnight Refrigeration Necessary?

Chilling allows the potatoes to fully absorb the cheese sauce, resulting in a creamier texture and deeper flavor. Skipping this step may leave the dish watery.

What Can I Substitute for Heavy Cream?

For a lighter version, use half-and-half or evaporated milk, though the sauce will be less rich. Avoid skim milk, as it lacks the necessary fat content.

Can I Add Meat to This Dish?

Certainly. Diced ham, cooked bacon, or browned sausage make excellent additions. Mix them in before baking for a heartier casserole.

Why Is My Casserole Too Dry?

Overbaking or using too little sauce can cause dryness. Ensure the milk-to-cream ratio is correct, and cover with foil if the top browns too quickly.

Final Tips for Perfect Delmonico Potatoes

• Double the Batch for Crowds – This recipe scales well. Use a 9×13-inch dish for larger gatherings and increase baking time by 10–15 minutes.
• Experiment with Cheeses – Try a blend of Gruyère, Parmesan, or smoked Gouda for a more complex flavor profile.
• Add a Crunchy Topping – For extra texture, sprinkle buttered breadcrumbs or crushed crackers over the dish before baking.
• Make It Ahead for Holidays – Assemble the casserole 2 days in advance and bake just before serving to save time.

Conclusion

Delmonico Potatoes are a timeless, crowd-pleasing side dish that balances simplicity with indulgence. By following proper storage methods, reheating carefully, and customizing the recipe to your taste, you can enjoy this creamy, cheesy casserole at its best—whether fresh from the oven or as a next-day leftover. With these tips and solutions to common questions, you’re equipped to make this classic dish a staple in your recipe collection.

Pin Recipe Print Recipe

Delmonico Potatoes

Delmonico Potatoes are a timeless and indulgent side dish, famously named after the historic Delmonico’s restaurant of 19th-century New York. This creamy potato casserole is made with shredded potatoes baked in a velvety cheddar cheese sauce, accented by warm spices and a golden-baked finish. Ideal for holidays, dinner parties, or comforting family meals, it’s a classic dish that’s both elegant and satisfying.

Prep Time15 minutes mins

Cook Time45 minutes mins

Total Time1 hour hr

Course: Side Dish

Cuisine: American

Servings: 6

Calories: 335kcal

Ingredients

• 20 oz pre-shredded Simply Potatoes 1 bag
• 3/4 cup milk 1% or preferred type
• 3/4 cup whipping cream
• 1 teaspoon kosher salt
• 1 teaspoon dry mustard
• Freshly ground black pepper to taste
• Freshly grated nutmeg to taste
• 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese
• 3 tablespoons butter sliced into 6 pats
• Paprika for sprinkling

Instructions

• Generously butter an 8×8-inch casserole dish and spread the shredded potatoes evenly inside.
• In a saucepan over medium-high heat, combine milk, whipping cream, kosher salt, dry mustard, pepper, and nutmeg. Stir and heat until the mixture is nearly boiling.
• Reduce heat and stir in the shredded cheddar cheese until melted and smooth.
• Pour the cheese sauce evenly over the potatoes in the casserole dish. Let it cool slightly.
• Dot the top with butter slices and sprinkle with paprika.
• Cover tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 12 hours or overnight.
• When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 350°F. Remove the plastic wrap and bake uncovered for 45 minutes, or until golden and bubbly.
• Notes
• Refrigerate leftovers promptly and reheat in the oven until warmed through.
• Leftovers can be frozen and reheated later.
• Customize the cheese or add herbs (like thyme or chives) for extra flavor.